Estable Studio Free call ES

Your Google reviews disappeared: why it happens and what you can do

Yesterday you had your reviews and today they're gone, or customers say they left one and it never showed up. Here's what to check first, why Google removes real reviews and what you can do.

A customer at your salon shows you on her phone the five-star review she left last week. It's nowhere on your profile. And when you count the rest, only 12 of the 40 you had are left. You never bought reviews or did anything shady, and they still disappeared.

It's not just you, and there's an explanation. There isn't always a fix, but there are steps that help. If you're still setting up your profile, the complete Google Business Profile guide covers the basics.

First, find out what happened

Before you contact anyone, check three things:

  1. Search your email, including spam and promotions, for a message from Google about your Business Profile. If Google plans to put a restriction on your profile, it tells you by email.
  2. Sign in to your profile at business.google.com with the business's account and look for a notice at the top.
  3. Look yourself up on Google Maps from someone else's phone, the way a customer would. See whether the reviews show, how many there are, and whether Google has posted a message under them.

What you find tells you which case is yours: a restriction on the whole profile, a few reviews Google removed, or new reviews that just haven't shown up yet.

Why reviews go missing

Google checks reviews to make sure they follow its rules. Its page on missing or delayed reviews gives several reasons:

  • New reviews go through a check that can take a few days. A review from yesterday might show up next week.
  • If a customer can't post a review, their Google Maps app may be out of date. Google suggests updating it.
  • If two listings for your business were merged, reviews from both can take a few days to appear.
  • Google may turn off reviews for a while on some profiles or for some types of business.
  • If your profile was suspended and then reinstated, reviews are sometimes lost.
  • Reviews Google removes for breaking its rules are removed for good. Google says plainly that it won't restore them.

The trouble is that those checks make mistakes too, and sometimes they take reviews from real customers. Google emails you before it puts a restriction on your profile, but its help pages don't promise to tell you which reviews it removed or why.

If Google put a restriction on your profile

This is the serious one. According to Google's page on restrictions for policy violations, when it believes a profile had fake reviews, it can do things like these:

  • stop the profile from getting new reviews for a period of time;
  • hide the reviews you already had, also for a period of time;
  • show a warning on your profile telling customers that fake reviews were removed.

That same page has the form to ask Google to review your profile. Explain what happened calmly and with facts: how long you've been in business, how you ask customers for reviews, and that you never offered anything in return. Google says it re-reviews the profile with whatever you tell it and tells you whether it lifts the restriction.

Appeal only once. On its page about how to appeal, Google asks you not to send several appeals for the same issue before you get an answer, and says a decision can take up to 5 business days. Don't open a new profile for the same business either: Google asks you not to.

Don't pay anyone who promises to bring your reviews back Google says reviews it removes for breaking its rules don't come back. If someone calls or messages you to charge you for recovering them or "cleaning up" your profile, they can't keep that promise. And if they offer you reviews, that's worse: it's exactly what Google punishes.

Check whether anything could have looked like cheating

Even if you did nothing wrong, it's worth going over Google's rules on reviews. Plenty of businesses do these things in good faith, and Google doesn't allow them:

  • Giving something for a review: a discount, a free dessert, a raffle for everyone who leaves one.
  • Giving your employees a target for how many reviews they need to get.
  • Asking for reviews that mention something specific, like the name of the barber who cut their hair.
  • Asking only the customers you know will give you five stars.
  • One person writing reviews from several accounts, even a relative who meant well.

If any of this was happening, stop it today and tell your team. And if someone who helped with your social media was doing it, ask them what they did.

Keep asking for reviews, the way you always have

This is what helps most, even if it's hard to believe right after losing the ones you had. The reviews Google removed won't come back, but new ones still count.

Google gives you a link and a QR code that take customers straight to writing a review. According to its help on creating the link or QR code, you go to your profile and select "Read Reviews," then "Get more reviews." You can copy the link from there, but the QR code can only be made from a computer, not a phone, so do it once, save it and print it for the register.

Send the link by WhatsApp to every customer when the job is done: when you hand back the car at the shop in Caguas, when you finish a haircut in Bayamón. Keep it short: "Thanks for coming in. If you have a minute, a Google review helps us a lot," plus the link. Ask everyone, not only the customers who were happy, and a little at a time: don't send the link to your whole customer list on the same day. If you have a WhatsApp button on your website, those chats are a good moment to ask.

If the problem is that your profile doesn't show up on Maps at all, not just the reviews, read why your business doesn't show up on Google Maps.

If you'd rather not handle the profile yourself

You can do all of this yourself, and hopefully the steps above are enough. If you'd rather someone else set it up, the Starter (from $499 one-time plus a monthly plan) and Business (from $1,200 one-time plus a monthly plan) plans include setting up your Google Maps profile along with your website. And if you need a change on the profile later, you send us a text, like any other change in the monthly plan. The Google Business Profile guide has a twenty-minute monthly routine for looking after it yourself. See plans and prices or book a free 30-minute call, in English or Spanish.

Questions

Why did Google delete my reviews if they were real?

Because Google decided they broke its rules. Its checks sometimes get it wrong and take real reviews with them, and its help pages don't promise to tell you the reason for each one.

What is a review restriction and how long does it last?

It's a penalty Google applies when it believes your profile had fake reviews: you can't get new reviews, or it hides the ones you had, for a period of time. Google doesn't say how long. It tells you by email before applying it.

Can I appeal, and how long does it take?

Yes, with the form on Google's page about restrictions. Appeal once and wait: Google says a decision can take up to 5 business days.

Will my reviews come back?

Reviews Google removed for breaking its rules won't. If they were hidden by a restriction and Google lifts it, they may show again. The safe bet is to keep asking your customers for reviews starting today.

Want it done for you?

A free 30-minute call in Spanish or English. We’ll tell you what your business needs and what it costs.